Home » WTCD Compendium » The Demolition of the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001 » General Posts

Are those debunkers' papers really peer-reviewed?

gretavo's picture
Submitted by gretavo on Tue, 2008-03-04 00:16.

Yeah, apparently they are still being reviewed...  I wonder what the hold up is?  And you know what?  I really hope that the Asif Usmani who contributed to the cover-up papers listed below isn't related to the Adaner Usmani who was one of the student organizers of today's controlled left Palestinian rights vigil.  It's very odd in any case that the student leaders of the controlled left at Harvard all happen to be Indian...

 

Charlotte Roben, A. Usmani, G. Flint, A. Jowsey, and D. Lange; Tall building collapse mechanisms initiated by fire: Part 1, Mechanisms Explained; submitted to the Structural Engineer, July 2007; under review as of 13/11/07

David Lange, C. Roben, A. Usmani; Tall Building collapse mechanisms initiated by fire: Part 2, Design Method; submitted to the Structural Engineer, July 2007; under review as of 13/11/07

http://www.see.ed.ac.uk/fire/publications.html

‹ General PostsupFormer NIST Fire Chief Questions WTC Collapses ›
»

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
gretavo's picture

looks like the paper was rejected...

Submitted by gretavo on Fri, 2008-03-21 20:50.

In any case it has vanished from Usmani's institution's site... unless I'm missing something, can someone alert the debunkers? They'll be sure to want to remove their links to it... Thanks!

»